Repair VS Replace

To repair or replace, that is the question. Let's discuss some factors that may help you decide.

1. Visible Signs of Wear and Tear:

   • Rotting Wood: Wooden fences are susceptible to rotting over time, especially in humid or damp conditions. Check for soft or discolored areas on the wood, as these are indications of decay.

   • Rust on Metal Fences: If you have a metal fence, inspect it regularly for signs of rust. Rust not only compromises the structural integrity of the fence but also affects its visual appeal.

   • Damaged Hinges: If your gate no longer latches or swings freely, it could be a sign it needs replaced.

2. Leaning or Sagging:

   • Post Instability: A fence that is leaning or sagging could be a result of unstable or deteriorating fence posts. If attempts to realign the fence prove futile, it might be time for a replacement. Evaluate if the soil around the post has been compromised or if the post itself has lost structural integrity.

3. Loose or Missing Fasteners:

   • Broken or Missing Nails and Screws: Inspect the fence for loose or missing fasteners. If there are numerous instances of broken or missing nails and screws, it could signify that the fence is no longer holding together properly. Not all fasteners are created equal. If the fence was constructed without ring shank nails, screws or staples; the fasteners could be susceptible to loosening over time.

4. Mold and Mildew Growth:

   • Stains and Discoloration: Mold and mildew can not only compromise the appearance of your fence but also weaken its structure. Stains, discoloration, or a fuzzy appearance are signs that mold may be present. Be sure to treat the mold with a cleaner that will not further damage the material therein making the issue worse.

5. Insect Damage:

   • Termite Infestation: Wooden fences are susceptible to termite infestations, leading to severe structural damage. Regularly inspect for signs of termite activity such as small holes, sawdust-like material, or hollow-sounding wood. Termite fence damage is uncommon in the Boise metro area and pressure treated wood is insect resistant. However, if the pickets have significant damp ground contact it could cause an issue.

6. Excessive Movement:

   • Wobbly Sections: If certain sections of the fence wobble excessively or are easily pushed, it indicates a lack of stability. This may be due to compromised fence posts or weakened support. Also, with the high winds that are prevalent in the treasure valley, FFI recommends not exceeding 6 feet between posts to attain maximum stability and long term durability of the fence.

7. Fading and Peeling Paint:

   • Loss of Protective Coating: Fading and peeling paint not only diminish the aesthetic appeal of the fence but also leave it vulnerable to the elements. A fresh coat of paint might no longer be sufficient, and replacement could be necessary. Look for a oil base stain that penetrates deeply into a wood fence for maximum protection from the elements.

8. Costs

   • Repair costs can add up: Its important to weight the costs of replacing or repairing multiple sections of fence against the cost to replace the fence. For example, a badly damaged wood fence may cost almost as much to repair as it would to replace with a vinyl or chain link that may have a significant increase in lifespan and reduced maintenance.

Regular inspection and maintenance are key to ensuring the longevity of your home fence. By paying attention to these signs of wear and tear, homeowners can make informed decisions about when it's time to replace their fence. Prompt action will not only enhance the curb appeal of the property but also contribute to the overall safety and security of the home. If you notice any of these signs, it may be time to consult with a fencing professional at FFI to assess the extent of the damage and determine the best course of action for replacement. 208-810-1669.